Showing posts with label Serena's Blog. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Serena's Blog. Show all posts

Tuesday, December 9, 2014

Are We Allegheny?

At the beginning of this semester, as I entered into my first weeks of classes, it was so crystal clear to me that black and brown lives matter, that women’s lives matter, that transgender lives, queer lives matter, that it seemed, at least in my circles, a given. Common knowledge. Not something that needed special clarification. As I progressed through the semester, however, and encountered so many people who thought otherwise — so many people who were dedicated to defending police brutality, to claiming that “it’s not about race” or it shouldn’t be — that it became increasingly clear to me how little progress we, as a society, have really made. There are still people dedicated to maintaining the existing structures of power. That’s no surprise. But hearing people close to me claim that the problem lie in the hands of the oppressed; that the murder of young black men and women (or really anyone who was a “them” in some way or another) is justified by the “crimes” they may or may not have committed. We have studied the way that Bodies are perceived, coded, and ranked in this society. It’s not hard to find articles, videos, or any type of media example of how disturbingly true this is. There’s a long — and growing — list of examples for me to pick from. 



Whether we’re looking “macro” at society as a whole — at American society, for the sake of this argument — or at the “micro” of Allegheny’s campus, we are far from the “post-racial” society that I’ve heard about. We’re not post- anything, because that assumes that there’s a finish line to cross and that’s it for systemic oppression. The idea that “women earn seventy five cents to a man’s dollar” isn’t even true, because it is the white woman who earns this compared to a white man’s dollar. Actually researching the researching the figures for the median earnings of men and women of many races was not difficult to find, but it was not reflective of the falsely-labeled “equal” and “post-racial” society that America consists of. Just looking at those statistics shows the way that certain bodies are literally worth more in the workforce than others. Overall, men earn several thousand dollars more than their female peers and white people earn more than Black and Hispanic people. It’s even further complicated by motherhood.  This article talks about how “nonmothers [were offered] an average of $11,000 more than mothers for the same high salaried job” even when the qualifications were identical. This kind of oppression shows in literally every aspect of life — at work, in school, at home, in conversations between multiple groups of people. Though the statistics I shared were specific to discrimination in the workplace, it’s not hard to connect them to other statistics and current events. 

(Trigger Warning for Slurs, Rape, Abuse); "All Oppression is Connected" by Staceyann Chin

Following the failure to indict the police officers involved in the deaths of Eric Garner and Michael Brown, I found:
  • …an article about a former police officer who was convicted of a felony for shooting an elk. (I wish I was kidding). This police officer— who, yes, broke the law, but that’s not the point—was given a harsher punishment for ending the life of an animal than was given to the people who caused the deaths of countless people of marginalized communities.
  • …that “they broke the law anyway” and “the officer was just doing his job” are seen as justifications for what has been happening for the entire history of this nation. It’s reminiscent of what Kate Bornstein termed “gender defenders” — but on an intersectional level. The “defenders” here do not simply uphold the binary; they simultaneously cling to the existing structures that uphold racial hierarchies, sexed hierarchies, and class hierarchies. 
  • …another article, detailing the psychology of prejudice, which described and then linked to an implicit bias test meant to measure prejudice, subconscious or conscious connections we’ve made with certain races and ideals. There’s a reason why police officers are more likely to use deadly or excessive force on black bodies — and it’s not because black bodies are more likely to be violent towards police. 
Broadening my search, I also found:
  • …that yet another transgender Black woman was killed while seeking refuge, adding another name to the long list of trans women (specifically trans women of color) who have been killed.
  • …that forced sterilization was only recently banned in California prisons. (Women of color and poor women were targeted specifically; especially if they already had children and could be seen as “at risk” of getting pregnant again)
  • …that the US has been deporting Latino/a people unlawfully and hastily, because their voices are not valued. 
  • …that, overwhelmingly, the horror stories of injustice in America, of the failures of the judicial system are stories of marginalized communities; that, yes, this is about race. It is about sex, about gender identity, about the perceptions that certain groups of people are innately better or worse than other groups.
  • …that our college is currently under investigation for Title IX Sexual Violence policy violations by the Department of Education’s Office for Civil Rights. Because the trauma of human beings, the violence that they are subjected to, has not been enough to enact administrative action to rid the campus of these violent attackers and come up with a realistic and comprehensive plan for the prevention of future instances of sexual violence.
  • …that, even in the midst of our celebration of the Bicentennial, even in the midst of our continuing year(s) of Civil Rights, in honor of the 50th anniversaries of the Civil Rights and Voting Rights Acts, this school still refuses to recognize that there are large numbers of students who feel unsafe and that this needs to be addressed immediately, rather than having discussions about how we can make ourselves safer. 
About a month ago, Dr. Lani Guinier came to this campus to talk about the importance of having truly diverse and open spaces for dialogue, about the sheer necessity of bringing different perspectives and experiences to the table in the name of progress. On this campus, however, her words failed to reach those most in need. Take, for example, Yik Yak and its nearly constant stream of racist/sexist/homophobic comments, sitting neatly next to jokes about finals or the weather in Meadville. There exists on this campus a huge divide between those dedicated to social justice and “the rest of us”. The college campus as a whole has not been willing to come forward to actually and willingly discuss the problems that are daily occurrences for certain students; that these things are physically or emotionally preventing students from performing academically.

Last night, I sat in on the second Community at Allegheny meeting. A mix of students, faculty, and administrators (though, I’ll be blatantly honest, it was student-heavy and missing nearly half of the administrators from the president’s cabinet), we were given a list of previously recorded demands and asked to sort through them, look for themes, discuss the major themes, and come up with possible solutions for some of those demands. Overwhelmingly, we asked the administration to be held accountable - through things as creative as administrative “RSE”-esque reviews, office hours for higher ranking college employees, and the simple request for transparency in their decisions about our academic (and personal!) lives. While we were expected, in the time of the community meeting, to come up with major action suggestions for the administration to implement, we were continually told that “progress has been made” on certain fronts and that we could be “assured” that the administration cares. But overall, the feeling has been that, as students, we have been given the weight of fixing the system that has prevented us from feeling 100% safe; that it’s our responsibility to fix our own oppression.


Thursday, November 20, 2014

Are Women Persons? Well, That Depends....

It’s become so worn out, so overdone, that it almost feels cliche to state. Those who align themselves with pro-life beliefs often argue that life begins at conception, that pregnancy is sacred, that the fetus - the baby, child, however they chose to label it - deserves protection at all costs… but once that fetus leaves the womb? The same group of people who so militantly “protected” the life of that fetus are often the ones who cut down attempts to protect the child and their mother. The same politicians who so vocally condemn abortion are the ones who have made it so difficult for pregnant women and new mothers to receive the assistance that they deserve throughout the pregnancy as well as during the first few years of their child’s life. 

Our healthcare system is deeply flawed in this country. Susan Bordo draws from Katha Pollitt, quoting a section from “Fetal Rights: A New Assault on Feminism”: 
Judges order pregnant addicts to jail, but they don’t order treatment programs to accept them, or Medicaid, which pays for heroin treatment, to cover crack addiction— let alone order landlords not to evict them, or obstetricians to take uninsured women as patients, or the federal government to fund fully the Women, Infants, and Children supplemental feeding program, which reaches only two-thirds of those who are eligible. The policies that have underwritten maternal and infant health in most of the industrialized west since World War II—a national health service, paid maternity leave, direct payments to mothers, government-funded day care, home health visitors for new mothers, welfare payments that reflect the cost of living—are still regarded in the United States by even the most liberal as hopeless causes, and by everyone else as budget-breaking giveaways to the undeserving, pie-in-the-sky items from a mad socialist’s wishlist. (83-4)
The healthcare and reproductive rights debate is often one of choice vs sanctity of life; we often fail to even account for the complexities surrounding reproductive rights. It’s true that women’s bodily autonomy is important when thinking about pregnancy and reproductive rights, but we fail to go beyond the choice to end or continue a pregnancy. Pollitt talks about our failure to fully fund Women, Infants and Children, which, ideally, would provide comprehensive health care, including resources like food, medicine, and check-ups to every pregnant woman — and child up to five years of age — who is “at risk” medically or financially. Pollitt states that those policies have existed in “most of the industrialized west since World War II,” but are seen as “hopeless causes” in America. Bordo even notes that there existed a government task force that came to the conclusion that “if we just delivered routine clinical care and social services to pregnant women, we could prevent one-quarter to one-third of infant mortality” (84).  The answer is so obvious that it seems absurd. But if we look deeper — if we, as Bordo asserts “leave the realm of rationality and enter the realm of gender ideology (and, in many cases, of racial prejudice as well)” we can see the complexities of this system of reproductive control (78). 

The political cartoon I attached at the beginning of this blog post is further complicated if we look at the mother as poor, as a woman of color, or as a woman who immigrated to America. If she is any of these things — not to mention a combination of those identity groups — she is, somehow, unworthy of care or protection. Poor women, women on welfare or other types of assistance, have historically been subjected to forced sterilization in order to prevent what is talked about in the Walker v. Pierce example: 
“[T]his is my tax money paying for something like this [having children while poor]… I am tired of people going around here having babies and my tax money paying for it” (79-80). 
Obviously, because someone pays their taxes they’re allowed to make decisions about other, lower-socio-economic-status people’s lives… right? Here, a person’s autonomy is tied to their ability to be a productive citizen — at least in the context of working. This woman, along with many other “non-productive” women, have been subjected to forced sterilization under the assumption that they were being given a kind of solution to the “problem” that was their economic status. Their personhood — as well as their literal ability to procreate — was taken from them because, as an exploited class, they were stripped the power to speak for themselves. In the same country where we have a problem teaching young people comprehensive sex education, unbiased and without any motive save for education, we have punished people (historically: disabled, non-white, non-English-speaking, poor people) for not knowing what we didn’t teach them — rather, for our perception that they did not understand what we refused to teach them about reproduction. To withhold comprehensive sex education and then punish those who do not adhere to our conception of correct knowledge (and correct bodies in which to practice that knowledge) is something the United States has certainly been guilty of.


In this country, we seem to operate on a model of savior-ism, while, in reality, suppressing and oppressing the groups we have claimed to have saved. We (and I’m using “We” to describe the current and popular beliefs in society, not my specific beliefs) seem to believe that people who make decisions that are divergent to our perceived correct decision are in need of help; they simply need to see the right way to go about things — and this extends to our backwards conception of pregnancy and childbearing. We have set up a system in which women can only fail. If women decide to carry the pregnancy to term, and are not married, middle- or upper-class, able bodied, white, or any number of privileged groups, we see them as a drain on society. If women decide to terminate a pregnancy because of a number of reasons (not limited to financial reasons like the cost of raising a child or simply not wanting to have children), we vilify them for putting themselves first, for electing to not bring a child into a world where there are little to no resources for them. 

Lauren Zuniga performs "To the Oklahoma Lawmakers" in response to invasive reproductive rights legislation

Tuesday, September 9, 2014

Bye-nary: Repurposing and Redefining (Inter)sex

When I first read Reis’ articles, what struck me was the pattern (in history, but leaking into modern medical procedures) of denying the existence of intersex individuals – relegating them to a subject of mythology, literally, by naming them “hermaphrodites” and then asserting that real intersex individuals had to fit into the gender binary somehow, and there was no other option. In a different class, I read Fausto-Sterling’s “The Five Sexes,” which, though it described gender and sex on more of a continuum – the title itself gives it away – she used language like “male hermaphrodite” to describe the different variations that sex may exhibit. Though I took issue with her terminology – finding “hermaphrodite” outdated and somewhat of a slur – I understood and agreed with her basic principle: that, biologically, sex has more variation in nature than a male/female dichotomy. If we use Fausto-Sterling’s idea of sex, it would look more like this:

A: Entirely Male
B: Somewhat Male (She used “male pseudohermaphrodite” here)
C: Gender Neutral/Exhibiting both male and female traits perfectly (“true hermaphrodite” here)
D: Somewhat Female (“female pseudohermaphrodite” here)
E: Entirely Female

and it is more comprehensive than the historical conception of sex as an either/or. Though this definition of biological sex works within the idea of the binary as opposing ends of a spectrum, at least it acknowledges that the spectrum exists. It does rely on biology, but this conception – to me at least – seems to be more inclusive and less biased towards cultural or social norms. It also pushes against the idea that children should be raised as male or female – that they can exist in between and still be legitimate, whole, and possibly more true to themselves – which is something that I believe to be integral when considering the political and personal of being an intersex person. I also think that this, if we were to somehow instate it in a medical context (and I’m saying this purely ideally; I understand that stigmas and old beliefs may hinder this), we could possibly provide better education for the parents of intersex individuals, and end the pattern of “corrective” surgery performed on infants. I understand, however, that this seems far-fetched – I haven’t yet negotiated how to address the issue of “fixing” babies behind closed doors, without the consent of the parents (or the individual themselves!) and the lack of information passed between the medical community and the patients/parents.


            But I believe that there is a unique relationship between intersex individuals and the parents of those individuals because of the way that society has emphasized – as well as hidden – the way that gender and sex are policed, coded, and assigned to “ambiguous” bodies. There also seems to be a divide between the bodies and the individuals themselves – especially from what we’ve read up to this point.  There’s a divide between the emotional/mental identity of a person and their physical being – one that, in my opinion, cannot and should not be severed.

“Medical experts estimate that one of every two thousand people is born with questionable gender status... Our gendered world forces us to put all people into one of two categories when, in fact, as the Harvard University biologist Anne Fausto-Sterling has suggested, we need to consider the ‘less frequent middle spaces as natural, although statistically unusual.’
Sex is social and historical, in large part a construction whose contours and boundaries have been imposed rather than simply discovered” (Reis 413).


Regardless of the accuracy of the “one in two thousand” statistic (I’ve read elsewhere that the estimate is as low as 1 in 4,500), the fact that these people’s voices need to be heard (and historically have been silenced) still stands. Historically, it seems, doctors did their “best” to make the physical and mental “match” – or at least the physical and the expected role that body was to fit into in society. But from the records we’ve seen, the doctors often made mistakes (to put it very lightly) – ones that essentially stuffed people who existed in a grey area into a constricting and imperfect box that did not fit their self-identity, nor did it fit the body they exist in.  In an article I read titled “What If It’s (Sort of) a Boy and (Sort of) a Girl?”, an intersex person relates this practice of corrective assignment surgery to the Nuremberg Code (in reference to the “monster ethics” of Nazi doctors, who sterilized and experimented on their prisoners).  I found this statement incredibly compelling because of its implications: the subject/patient here does not get to consent (which is a violation of the first principle of that code), and does not have a valid reason (save for upholding the binary and ensuring a heteronormative society can continue).

From that same article I mentioned earlier, I found this quote: "intersex babies are not having difficulty with sexual identity or self-image. The parents are...” and it seemed, to me, to summarize my overall issue with assigning gender/sex to an infant -- as well as my issue with performing surgery that is not at all medically necessary on a human who cannot consent to what I'm hesitant to call something cosmetic. From that same article I mentioned earlier, I found this quote: "intersex babies are not having difficulty with sexual identity or self-image. The parents are...” and it seemed, to me, to summarize my overall issue with assigning gender/sex to an infant -- as well as my issue with performing surgery that is not at all medically necessary on a human who cannot consent to what I'm hesitant to call something cosmetic.