Showing posts with label Jeannie's Blog. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Jeannie's Blog. Show all posts

Wednesday, December 3, 2014

To sterilize....is to force?


With Susan Bordo’s “Are Mothers Persons?” we were discussing the key words and phrases, and talking about what each means: bodily integrity, informed consent, subjectivity, and lastly involuntary sterilization. Here are some of the brief definitions that I jot down for each of those terms.

Bodily integrity: intrinsic for bodies to have their own space—not meant to be violated—rights are protected
Informed consent: person is given all the options and consequences, and then making the person’s own choice and decision
Subjectivity: you and yourself are protected by the law, your self have rights; your self is an actual being
Involuntary sterilization: usually done to poor people who are usually on assistance from the state; therefore their bodily integrity is greatly diminished; they are seen as expendable by big hospitals, even doctors have performed involuntary sterilization as practice on those people

As we were going through each of these terms, when we came to the phrase “involuntary sterilization,” I was really unsure of what this term entailed, but I knew it was an act that violated the women’s bodily integrity. In addition, it was not done with informed consent; instead it was performed on the women without their knowledge. Plus, I was thinking of sterilization in terms of microbiology as in any process that eliminates (removes) or kills all forms of life, including transmissible agents such as virus, bacteria, etc. present on a surface, contained in a fluid, in medication, or in a compound such as biological culture media.

One of the tools needed for the sterilization process. 

However, as I was reading “Conquest: Sexual Violence and American Indian Genocide” by Andrea Smith, the term sterilization was brought up again. Before I read further, I looked up the definition of this term, and I found the act of sterilizing is defined as depriving someone of their ability to reproduce by blocking or removing their sex organs. I was shocked and ashamed of my ignorance because I did not bother to look up this term when I was unsure of its meaning.

Touching upon the chapter titled “Better Dead Than Pregnant,” I learned that involuntary sterilization was performed on Native American women in order to control the population of the Native American. Not only that, but this procedure was also performed on racial groups of color and the poor class who are often abusers of drugs and alcohol. As long as this practice is being performed on these oppressed groups, the concept of bodily integrity is disregarded as well as the ability to make one’s own choices and decisions. For example, in relating to the wealth status of women, historian Rickie Solinger states that the concept of “choice” is connected to possession of resources. As he states,

“Choice” also became a symbol of middle-class women’s arrival as independent consumers. Middle-class women could afford to choose. They had earned the right to choose motherhood, if they liked. According to many Americans, however, when choice was associated with poor women, it became a symbol of illegitimacy. Poor women had not earned the right to choose.

It is upsetting to read that individuals’ freedom of rights is based on the individual’s wealth status because of the resources that are being made available to those who can really afford it. That means those who are poor are not even given the choice to decide if they want to have children or not. That choice is taken away from them through involuntary sterilization because those in a higher position with the ability to choose to give the procedure (as in physicians and politicians) decide that the person should not have the chance to reproduce simply due to many reasons, necessary and also ridiculous.
Additionally, I found that along with Native American women with disabilities, involuntary sterilization was also done on women and girls with disabilities across the world. Some of the purposes for this violating procedure were population control, menstrual management and personal care, and pregnancy prevention (including pregnancy that results from sexual abuse).

Recently, the state of California just passed a bill that banned using sterilization as a form of birth control for the female inmates in all jails, prisons, and detention centers. Just last year, it was revealed that 148 women had undergone coerced sterilization which violated the prison rules between 2006 and 2010. An inmate, Crystal Nguyen who worked at a prison’s infirmary in 2007 recalled, “I was like, ‘Oh my God, that’s not right,’ Do they think they’re animals, and they don’t want them to breed anymore?” What she said demonstrated the viewpoint of the people who looks at women including those serving time, as “breeders” that should not even have the ability to reproduce. In the perspective of 34 years old Christina Cordero who went to prison for car theft, she remembers being pressured by the prison doctor: “As soon as he found out that I had five kids, he suggested that I look into getting it (tubal ligation—sterilization) done. The closer I got to my due date, the more he talked about it…He made me feel like a bad mother if I didn’t do it.” Since then, she has regretted making this decision that she made because she was emotionally manipulated and coerced.  
All of the examples that I mentioned about had in some form of the violation of one’s own rights, including the freedom of choice over one’s own body. In fact, the United Nations Special Rapporteur on violence against women has asserted that coerced sterilization is a method of medical control of a woman’s fertility. The entirety of this specific act violates a woman’s physical integrity and security and constitutes violence against women. This is something that everyone needs to know because even at this time, there are still people who do not realize the true severity of the lack of women’s reproductive rights and bodily integrity. We need to start advocating for women’s rights to have control over their own bodies, and make informed decisions in relating to their bodies because it is their bodies, not anyone’s.


Thursday, November 6, 2014

Don't Stare at Me

For this blog assignment, there are two things that I want to use: the YouTube video titled “10 Hours of Walking in NYC as a Woman” and the reading material, “Staring: How We Look” by Rosemarie Garland-Thomson. In class, we were discussing some of the ways women could do to avoid attention from men who are street harassing them. Staring straight ahead without glancing at your surroundings. Looking down while listening to music. Not responding to the street harassers. Not giving any indication of being interested at all whatsoever in the street harassers. There are endless ways women use to shield themselves from street harassers. Unfortunately, there are people out there who do not understand the reason why women are so “cold” to the street harassers because they do not consider it harassing, but rather as complimenting or appreciating. Those people are ignorant in that they do not realize the serious position that women are in. I can guarantee you that on the YouTube video comments, there are people bashing on the woman because they think it is not considered harassing or it’s the woman’s fault for somehow being too “attractive.” These people just do not realize the consequences of responding to the street harassment.

As I was going through my Tumblr dashboard, one of the people that I follow reblogged a post that listed several incidents of sexual, violent street harassment committed against women. Thankfully, there was a credible source on the post where a blogger talks about those incidents, specifically one where a guy pulled up in his car next to a 14 year old girl asking her to have sex with him for money. The girl responded by saying no. Try and guess what happened to her. She got ran over by the guy several times, and sustained life-threatening injuries. Thankfully, she survived, and identified the man thus, he was arrested. Obviously this is an extreme case, but the fact that these situations do happen is too frightening to think about. It shows that there is a large possibility of these acts occurring which is why women are afraid of what will happen if they do stand up to the catcalling and the sexual harassing.

On the other hand, I saw a YouTube video that showed the exact replication of the video, “10 Hours of Walking in NYC as a Woman” except for the fact that it was located in Auckland. In this video, the woman received no street harassment which indicated that the location has a lot to do with street harassment which we talked about in class. In fact, my high school best friend and I traveled to London this past summer, and we have encountered several street harassments. There was one instance where my friend and I had to separate because she had to go back to the hotel to get something she forgot. My friend told me that there were a couple of strangers asking her for directions. But, she knew that they were not tourists because they had British accents. She politely declined, and from thereon, she started wearing earphones, and just walked straight ahead to her destination. So, really street harassment can happen at almost everywhere. But, then what about places like Auckland? Does this mean that Auckland is that much of an ideal society where women are treated with respect that they deserved? Or is there another side to Auckland that we do not really know? This is what I was thinking while watching that video, and I was very confused. If you have any answers, please tell me!
photo credit: Collective Action for Safe Spaces
In addition to the street harassment, I thought about how staring plays into the harassment part. In the NYC video, we could see almost all of the street harassers blatantly staring at the woman. For this particular circumstance, staring at the woman was to objectify the woman sexually, basically only seeing her as a sexual object. In relating to the reading article on staring, Garland-Thomson, the author, talked about how staring was a violation of manner etiquette. There was one quote that I found to be interesting because it kind of disturbs the overall topic of street harassment. “To draw the stare through any eccentric behavior or appearance is to violate social decorum just as surely as does the act of staring.” What this statement means is that if the person is staring at another person, it is also the fault of the person being stared because that person is drawing attention to herself which violates the whole civilizing process. Garland-Thomson mentions many key points on staring; one example being that staring “validates individuality” meaning that it “calls out our differences from others.” I found this kind of ironic because what women want is not to be noticed by potential street harassers. Women just want to go about their daily routine without people noticing them, therefore harassing them.

The author also mentioned staring back at the person who is staring at you. If we applied this to everyday situations where women are walking on the streets, it is hard to say what kinds of results are bound to occur. In the worst case scenario, a woman stares back at her street harasser in response to his sexual, verbal harassment. The man would most likely be motivated by that response which then could possibly escalate into even more harassing, and worse, sexual assault. As for the positive case scenario, when the woman takes the chance to stare back at the harasser, the harasser may feel intimidated because the power dynamic has shifted from him to her. In an ideal world, it could even result a small, but significant change in the perspective of the harasser.

Yet, this is not the ideal world. There are people who have committed such extreme acts of sexual violence because they have been rejected by women who have taken the chance to stand up for themselves. For example, there was a woman who refused to give a man her phone number, and as a result, she was killed by the man with a gun. 

In response to the YouTube video of the woman in NYC, there was a video conference debate, and I thought I should end this blog with this video that I highly recommend you to watch. 


 

Tuesday, October 7, 2014

Fetish? Or not??

DSC_5016

As I was reading chapter three titled, “Sexy/Beautiful/Fat” from Kathleen LeBesco’s book, “Revolting Bodies: The Struggle to Redefine Fat Identity,” I was a bit taken back by the vivid descriptions from the magazine, “FaT GiRL: A Zine for Fat Dykes and the Women Who Want Them.” Truthfully speaking, I did not know much about fat politics, let alone knew it existed. But I am slowly learning something new about this topic as I continue to read this book. So, when I came across this specific section in regarding the sexual, erotic beauty in fat bodies, I did not expect it at all. My first thought when I read the descriptions of the photographs in the Zine magazine was is this not fetishization? Or did I come up with the wrong conception and that it was simply appreciating the female fat bodies?

I first came across the term fetishizing on Tumblr because people were blaming fanfiction writers for fetishizing homosexual relationships because they believed it to be damaging to the queer community as a whole in that the gay relationships depicted in these stories are not what they actually are in reality. I recommend reading this blog if you want to know more what I am talking about in terms of fetishizing and fanfiction. However, that is not my main purpose of this blog entry. I want to talk about apply fetishizing to fat women’s bodies, and what that really entails. Fetishizing is to make (something) the object of a sexual fetish. I found this definition when I typed it in google, and the fact that GOOGLE used this as an example makes me think things has definitely got to change: ‘women’s bodies are so intensely fetishized.’

In the following, there was an advice column where “The Invisible Blob” was worried about her thin girlfriend getting too much attention and feeling insecure. The response was along the lines of “FLAUNT IT!...Public Displays of Affection...you obviously have something very appealing to said gf…And by this, I mean more than a butt you can grip with both hands. You are great and beautiful. Revel in their pathos. Feel sorry for them.” After reading this, I was confused, and I had to read it a couple of times to fully understand it. I was unsure whether the responder was trying to say to the “Invisible Blob” to be confident in her curves because that is the reason why her girlfriend is dating her. But, this was not the case because the responder also mentioned “...more than a butt…” indicating there is more to the “Invisible Blob.”

What caught my eye and made me think was that “Unlike other liberatory texts that fete fat to protest the hegemony of thinness, FaT GiRL goes so far as to exclaim that fatness is the preferred way of being in the world.” I thought that this was biased because it is saying that fatness is the ultimate ideal while disregarding other physical body shapes. It seemed interesting that the author, LeBesco used this sexualized example of the zine to show that. Is she trying to prove that fat people should be focused on because of their sexual physicality?

To me, it felt like the author, LeBesco used the example of FaT GiRL to really demonstrate the sexuality of fat women and their bodies, but at one point, I thought it went too far when she included the detailed portrayal because I thought it was fetishizing fat women’s bodies. The reason why I thought so was because the magazine was highlighting and enhancing the fat curves of the women’s bodies. But, I did some outside research, and I found a personal firsthand experience from a women who have met people who were interested in her because of their fat fetish or they had a preference towards her plump curves. Through her account, I learned the true difference of fetishizing fat women and appreciating fat women. She said that those who were interested in her JUST because of her being fat were the people who had a fat fetish. They were the ones who were fetishizing her body, not who she really is as a person along with her body. On the other spectrum, she has met guys who truly wanted to get to know her personally, while at the same time appreciated her curves. Yet, the curves was not the main purpose of them meeting her. Since I learned this, going back to the advice column, I realized that it was not fetishization because the person who wrote the advice told the “Invisible Blob” that her girlfriend likes her because she sees something in her personality, not just because she is fat, and that she should be confident in herself as a beautiful person.

One of the examples of racial fetishization of Asian-Americans where in this picture, Asians are fetishized to look "cute" and "adorable" as if that is what they are supposed to be.

Not only can there be fetishization of fat women, but there are also fetishization of women’s bodies: breasts, legs, butt, etc. Plus, there is the fetishizing of racial women who are African-American, Asian, Latino, and so much more. What is more, I must not forget, there is fetishizing of transgendered, gay, lesbian, basically the whole LGBT group. All in all, fetishization of the women occurs in every aspect: body, race, culture, and sexuality. As of now, what is not surprising to me is that the most common form of fetishization in the United States is racial fetishization of women and even men. It is so prevalent in today’s society due to popular culture, media, and art. There have been so many instances where Asians and African-Americans are objectified and stereotyped. Even I have experienced this many times throughout the course of my life. I do not intent to get into detail about my personal account. Instead, I wanted to bring attention to the fact that fetishizing women goes in hand with objectifying and stereotyping women because both of these acts completely disregards who the women really are in terms of personality and intellectual; essentially what makes up a person. This occurs in many different ways, and that it is an issue in the topic of feminism.

So, as I finish up my blog, I talked on a very large scale of topics, from fetishizing fat women’s bodies to briefly on contrasting forms of fetishization. But, the big question that I want to leave with you, is what can be done to stop the objectifying? The fetishizing? The stereotyping? These are such large issues that it seems impossible to even think of tackling them. Will people ever learn that this is wrong? That it is not right to be even doing that to women, and taking away their identities? Therefore, please do let me know what you guys, the audience, think about this overwhelming situation.

 

Monday, September 22, 2014

Hmm...Isn't the alphabet soup missing something?


As I was reading through “An Introduction to Transgender” by Susan Stryker, she provided a list of terms and definitions that were related to the topic of transgender: sex, gender, gender role, gender comportment, intersex, genderqueer, etc. In the midst of these words, there was one word and its meaning that struck me and made me question some things. The “Alphabet soup.” Stryker defines it as a figurative soup containing many acronyms that are used by members of the T section of the LGBTIQQA community which stands for Lesbian, Gay, Bisexual, Transgender, Intersex, Queer, Questioning, and Allies. I was surprised to read that there were more acronyms that were extended from beyond LGBT which is a pretty common term nowadays. However, I noticed that there was something missing from the alphabet soup. There was no acronym for Asexuality. Even though there was a category for those who are unsure of what to label themselves as which is the “Questioning,” it is not truly the same as Asexuality. What happens if some people are unable to label themselves as gay or lesbian or even straight? Because they really do not have any interest in sex? Because they do not really feel any sexual attraction to people? Those people would then be considered asexual. But, why is asexuality not part of the alphabet soup?

What is asexuality? The most common known definition of the word, asexual, according to the official Asexuality website, is a person who does not experience sexual attraction. It is considered to be a sexual orientation, meaning it would also be categorized with the gay, lesbian, straight, and so on. To go further into asexuality, an asexual person is able to be attracted to people, and have meaningful relationships with them. The only difference is that an asexual person does not feel the need to have a sexual relationship, but instead focuses more on the relationship aspect: getting to really know someone, and be close to them emotionally.


So, my questions get stronger in that why is it excluded from the LGBTIQQA??? Based on my inferior experience, I have seen some occurrences online of prejudiced people who did not believe in asexuality because they did not consider it a sexual orientation. They thought it was incredulous to not have any sexual feelings toward someone one is dating in a relationship because they think, “If you like the person, would you not want to eventually have a sexual relationship with that person?” Additionally, asexual people are looked upon as if they are not even real. For instance, there are some people in the LGBT community who believe that asexuality is not even a sexual identity because of the lack of sexuality. Thus, there are prejudice and misconceptions. Prejudice due to the belief that asexual people do not experience the same oppression and discrimination as the LGBT people, therefore should not receive any particular attention. Misconception of asexuality itself, in that it is a preference, not a sexual orientation in that asexual people simply “choose” not to participate in sex which is not the case.

I can now at least understand why asexuality is never really mentioned in the alphabet soup. Even people in the LGBT community can be unaccepting towards people who are “misfits” whom in this situation are the asexual, which is very sad. This makes me wonder why they are so quick to judge people who also do not fit in society because of who they are. It seems kind of hypocritical in a way because the outcasts have their own community where they welcome “certain” kinds of outcasts, but they do not accept every outcast. In order to be part of that community, there must be specific requirements and rules that they must fulfill and follow . This relates back to the book that we read for class, “Whipping Girl”, where the author, Julia Serano, talked about being a transwoman, a person who was assigned the gender male at birth, but identifies as a female and lives as a female, and how she is not welcomed within the feminist community. The feminist community looked down upon transwomen because of their superiority of having a “real” gender as females over transwomen whose “female” gender is not real due to their original assigned gender as males. It’s ridiculous when you think about it, their reason for not accepting people who are just like them. Serano said something that I thought is very relevant, and can also be applied to the situation on asexuality. “There is no such thing as a “real” gender - there is only the gender that we experience ourselves as and the gender we perceive others to be.”

I thought this comic strip truly demonstrates what asexual people go through everyday. People not believing asexuality is a real thing, hence the pressuring questions. 

How this quote apply to asexuality is how some people in the LGBT community think that asexuality is not even a sexual orientation due to its lack of sexual attraction. Yet, who are they to state something like that when they may not even know what asexual people really go through? In reality, based on the personal accounts of asexual people from the article, "LGBT, Asexual Communities Clash Over Ace Inclusion," they have gone through a “coming out” period, and struggle with discrimination and alienation just as the LGBT people have. Despite the challenges, the LGBT community is now accepting the asexual community, realizing the true content of what it means to be asexual. Now, the two communities are finally cooperating and accepting each other which benefit them greatly for the future. In addition, there are people in the asexual community who wants to include asexuality in the LGBT acronym, but then there are some who wants to find their own independence, separate from the LGBT.

This answers my questions at the beginning, but as I am reaching toward the end of my blog, I am wondering why people feel the unconscious need to judge and hate something that does not belong within a category or restriction. Because this has happened many times throughout history: intersex, transgendered, gays, lesbians, and so much more. All of these people have experienced hatred and discrimination from society simply because they did not fit with society’s standards of what is normal. Obviously, there are many reasons why people are so hateful, like for example, it depends on religion, traditional values, their upbringing, etc. Nevertheless, it is to my belief that society are becoming more aware of these social issues, and that their mindset is changing (however, very, painstakingly slow) in that we will be able to accept people of every sexuality and gender.

Monday, September 8, 2014

Doctors vs. Intersex Patients


What really caught my attention in Elizabeth Reis’s "Impossible Hermaphrodites: Intersex in America, 1620-1960" was the ethical issues that were involved in many of the cases where the physicians performed surgery in which they decide the sex of their patients. In these examples, most of the doctors made these decisions due to the patients’ future marriage prospects, level of sexual desire, and other factors. Based on the text, it was noticeable how many of the patients did not have a say in which gender they identified with, especially those who were so young.

There was one case with a patient who lived the first two years of her life as a girl, but then started to shift her focus from dolls to “boyish sports.” A physician, Dr. Gross, closely examined her and found her to have ambiguous genitals in that she has a small clitoris and two testes despite her “long dark hair, dark eyes, perfectly formed hips and chest, arms and legs, and a lovely face.” Dr. Gross performed surgery to remove the testes of the young girl because he was thinking of her future marriage prospects. At that time, he strongly believed that it was better for her to be a woman with no sexual desire than a man fulfilled despite the fact that the patient was incapable of impregnation. While reading this particular case, this horrified me because the doctor made the decision for his patient simply due to her future marriage prospects. I could not believe how there was so much power in the doctor’s hands. It is unsure whether the young patient was given the free will to choose which sex she wanted to be, but it was most likely that she was not given a choice. Also, interestingly, it did not mention anything about the patients’ parents and their perspective on their child’s surgery. It was obvious that back then, there were many ethical issues involved in relating to the patients’ consent and the power in the physicians’ hands.

However, an opposite case involved a physician, Dr. Goffe who allowed his patient to have the opportunity to decide what gender the person wanted to be. The patient had physical male characteristics, yet was considered a woman by the physician because of the patient’s sexual preferences towards males. Despite Dr. Goffe’s strong beliefs in heterosexuality, thus regarding his patient as female, he asked his patient which gender she preferred to be. In this, we see the doctor giving his patient the power to choose which gender she wanted to live as. So, the patient decided to be female, and the doctor followed her wishes. During that time period, it was very rare, in fact so rare that Dr. Goffe received harsh criticism for giving his patient the power to choose genders.


Which leads me to my question: Should doctors be given the power to assign a gender to their patients who are very young or at birth? Through my research, I found that two years ago in 2012, physicians are still performing genital surgery on intersex infants at birth. In doing so, there were severe, harmful consequences especially with unsuccessful surgeries where the results are physical and psychological pain, scars, decreased sexual sensation, and many other issues. In addition, there are always the options of the person rejecting their gender assignment which is unfortunately irreversible. So, I wondered to myself, do the doctors even realize these severe consequences that they may possibly unknowingly inflict on their patients? Once I read this article, it answered my question in the form of “No.” It talked about the physicians’ reactions to the intersex woman who came to them asking for a sincere apology. They realized the true harm they have caused, and expressed regret. As you can see, the doctors should not really have that power in their hands because it is not up to them, but the intersex patient.

Though what caused these doctors to perform unnecessary and harmful “treatment” on intersex children? In fact, what caused all of these doctors to do these surgeries on children whose genitals look “not right?” It is society’s perception of what makes a human being normal in terms of physicality as well as mentality. Because the intersex are born with genitals that do not look like it should, doctors change the intersex’s genitals to a more normal shape of how it should be due to their mindset of enforcing the normality onto their intersex patients often without consent which then, violate their human rights. Nowadays, there is more awareness of intersex people and what they go through. Hopefully, we will learn to see them simply who they are as a person, instead of enforcing a gender on them, and defining them ourselves when it is not up to us.

To me, it seems that society is so focused on perfect, normal physical appearances that anything that is abnormal is immediately shunned from society which explains the doctors’ reasoning in assigning a gender to intersex people. Why do we focus so much on normality and perfection? Everyone is imperfect in some physical form of way. There are people who have scars, disability impairments, diseases, etc. Yet, we stressed so much on having the same physicality. Which brings me to my next thought: What makes a human perfect? What is perfection? Everyone has different ideas of what should be perfect, so is there such a thing as a united idea of perfection?  

As of now, times are changing, and people are realizing that everything is not always cut and dry. There are a variety of things such as sex preferences, sex gender, etc. that are fluid. Even I have learned something new from this course even though it is still the beginning of the semester. I was not aware of what intersex really meant until we read the course required readings. I actually realized that there was an in-between even within the sex genders. Therefore, I think the first step in realizing these topics is awareness.