Showing posts with label Catherine's Blog. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Catherine's Blog. Show all posts

Tuesday, December 9, 2014

Sterilization to Plan B: Native American Women Fight for Reproductive Agency.


In “Better Dead than Pregnant” Andrea Smith details the plight of Native American women who either want or do not want to get pregnant. Her article illustrates the racist and elitist ideas and thoughts behind Native American women and pregnancy. The main theme in this novel was the insistence on control of Native American women, especially on doctors controlling Native American women.

This control is asserted in several ways. First off the doctors already have a degree of control because they are seen as the experts, and defaulted to have the most knowledge. They also exert control by devaluing the opinion and thoughts of the Native American women by declaring racial superiority. They do this by taking charge of these women’s reproductive lives.

As Smith discusses doctors on reservations have a history of sterilizing women without their consent. For example about 50% of Native American women were sterilized in the 1970s. As Smith discuses this is a form of racial genocide. Doctors were intentionally lying to Native American women about the procedure they were about to undergo. Either by telling them they were getting a different procedure or telling them it was to fix minor complaints such as headaches. The decision was made exclusively by doctors and was usually based off of racist, outdated, ignorant stereotypes the doctors had about Native American women.

Doctors would preform sterilization procedures because they judged that Native American women would be bad mothers. Either because they already had “too” many children, or because they assumed based off of racist stereotypes that these women were drug addicts or had bad judgment. At the root of these sterilization procedures is the idea that these Native American women do not know how to take care of themselves. They do not know how to make their own decision. They are deemed too dumb, or too ignorant, or too helpless to be in charge of their own lives.

Native American women do not have control in their lives; they do not have control over how to live their lives. Andrea Smith proved this in the early 2000s with her article “Better Dead than Pregnant” and it can still be seen today in this article about emergency contraceptive access for Native American women. There was no choice about weather or not to undergo sterilization, that decision was often made by the doctor. Similarly with emergency contraceptives there is no choice because you cannot find emergency contraceptives on the reserve.

Plan B and equivalent medicines are not carried on reservations. If a woman wants to get an emergency contraceptive she must drive off the reservation at least an hour and not even been guaranteed to find emergency contraceptives. What’s more they would most likely not have the money or the means to get the emergency contraceptive. There is also very little information provided as to why emergency contraceptives are not available on reservations. Even after doing research the author of the article could not get a straightforward answer about why contraceptives aren’t available and what would have to be done to make them available.

Sterilization was used to try and stop Native Americans from reproducing and continuing to survive. It is important to fight back against sterilization so that Native American culture, heritage, and bloodline is not ended. While the problem with not having access to emergency contraceptives is that without it Native American women do not have the choice to not have children.

One of the reasons things like Plan B are important is because rates of sexual assault are very high for Native American women. It is often not a question of “if” but “when” these women will need access to contraceptives. Having access to Plan B can drastically change the amount of control and agency Native American women have over their lives. Just like sterilization was about the taking away agency from the women, not having access to Plan B is also about taking away agency.  
Because these women are a minority; because they live on reservations and their only source of healthcare comes through the US government; because they do not have systems in place to give them a voice or give them power their needs are ignored, and secondary to what others believe they need.

 There is also little interest from those who are in power, it allowing these women to gain power, or to gain agency. So, what does this mean for Native American women? It means progress is slow; it means that they are denied basic rights and it means that they are not seen as fully human.

Although sterilization and access to Plan B might seem like two separate and apposing issues the idea behind both is the same, control. Stripping Native American women of the right to making their own decisions and making their reproductive health another person’s jurisdiction keeps them from gaining power over their own lives. In a way it keeps them just as suppressed and enslaved as they were when settlers first tried to colonize Native Americans. These rules and barriers around reproductive health are just another form of genocide.

However, it does seem that there are some positive changes coming. There is policy being put in place so that Plan B can be give to Native American women without them having to go to the pharmacy or clinic for a visit. Instead it is starting to be treated as an over the counter medicine, meaning that the women will be able to order it from pharmacies and have it delivered to the reservation. This is all preliminary and is not in place yet, but is a promising step in allowing Native American women more agency over their reproductive choices.

Thursday, November 20, 2014

Miscarriages and Blame


There are 600,000 miscarriages annually. Many women expierence more than one miscarriage if they experience one at all. 10-20 percent of pregnancies end in miscarriages. 1 in 200 women will have a repeated miscarriage, meaning they will experience more than one. With miscarriages being so common it almost feels as if a part of being pregnant is the risk of miscarriages. As if an inherent part of possessing a pregnant body is running the risk of doing everything right and still not being able to keep your pregnancies.
     The women in Langston’s book Toxic Bodies certainly feel that having a miscarriage is an inherent part being pregnant. “… For women on the reservation have taken meticulous care of their health during their pregnancies, yet they still have high rates of pregnancy loss” (1). Sadly in their instance it doesn’t seem like there is much for these women to do, as the problem likes in environmental factors and not individual choices.  The chemicals causing the miscarriages also seem to still be around through generations and can affect women two generations removed from the original women who was affected by these environmental toxins. It has also been proven that even very low levels of these toxins can interfere with the life of a fetus. Yet these toxins have yet to be completely eliminated.
     In Borodo’s “Are Mothers Persons?” it is pointed out that recently fetuses have almost been granted super-subject status, as the right to a future life has taken priority over the mother’s right to her current full-fledged life. Mothers are villianized for wanted to make their own choices over doing everything they possibly can to avoid anything that might remotely harm the baby, even though the mother is a person with her own life and her own morals and the fetus has not yet born. Together these two ideas seem to conflict. In the one the very real and proven possibility of a toxin killing a fetus is not enough to get rid of the toxin. But the idea that a mother might do something even remotely dangerous to the health of the fetus is enough to make her into a villain.
     I think this discrepancy exists because in both cases if something goes wrong it comes back to hurt the mother, and can be blamed on the mother. With the toxins, despite the fact that they are known to be harmful there is also always the chance that when a miscarriage occurs it could have been caused by something the mother does. I think in our society we tend to believe that because some women are genetically designed to carry a fetus, the health and well being of that fetus are always in the hands of the mother. Because it exists in her body and relies on her for life, if anything goes wrong the blame lays with her.
     However, the mother is not allowed to act as if the fetus is a part of her body, she is not allowed to treat it as if she has control over it. If she starts to treat the fetus as if it is just another part of her body, and a part that she has autonomy and control over she is seen as incorrect and heartless as this fetus could become a child. When it comes to birth and pregnancy, the second a woman wants to take control over her body, she is met with resistance.
     I think there is an inherent double bind when a woman becomes pregnant. In society she is no longer a woman, but a mother, and immediately held to higher standards. Suddenly her life is not as important as the potential one she carries. She is no longer a person, but a mother and it becomes common and expected for her to do as she’s told and put the fetuses well being in front of her own. If she does not it is regarded the same as if she harmed or abused her own fully formed child. This directly links to women feeling upset and guilty after a miscarriage. Because they are so often place with all of the responsibility for anything that happens to the fetus they carry, when something does go wrong they are the ones that take blame.

     Many women also think that miscarriages are far and few in between and when they do have a miscarriage believe that is it a personal defect and that they are one of the few women to ever have a miscarriage. However, this is not true, not only are miscarriages more common than we are generally lead to believe, that are so many factors that can cause a miscarriage it is unrealistic and unfair to believe that the blame lays with the mother. Despite the fact that pregnancy is a common and encouraged part of life basic knowledge about pregnancy is rarely common knowledge. As this Huffington Post article explains, most women believe a lot of myths about pregnancy. 

Thursday, November 6, 2014

Exploitation, Art, and LeBesco



The piece Staring: How We Look by Garland-Thomson explores the use of art in helping people become more comfortable and familiar with disability. Two artists are cited as making able-bodied people explore how they react and look at disabled people by giving them the chance to stare without fear of offending or being perceived as rude. The artists also give the disabled people agency by allowing them to choose how to present themselves. In this way the art not only allowed the starers to look at the disabled people but it also gave the disabled persons agency in choosing how they would like to be presented. Although, in these instances I believe the subjects were given agency and in a way a voice, they were still being exploited. The point of the exhibits for both artists was too give able-bodied people the change to view the disabled people from a disabled person to just as person with a disability. However, the draw of the photos and of the exhibits was still that these people were disabled, meaning that there value and interest was still defined by their disability.
Let’s define exploitation. When I searched Google the definition that popped up was “The action or fact of treating someone unfairly in order to benefit from their work”. The first part of the definition is up for interpretation, how do we define whether or not someone was being treated unfairly? Were the subjects in these art pieces paid for helping? Where they given commission for how well the exhibit did? Where they fully aware of what their photos would be used for? One would hope that the answer to most or all of these questions is yes. However, from the articles it is unclear. It is definitely true that the artist benefited from the work or the input of the disabled people because the artists are the ones who made money and gained fame from the exhibit in a way that the subjects from the piece did not.
     So, yes, these subjects were exploited but in this sense is the exploitation bad? Or rather does the good from this exploitation outweigh the bad from it? For instance, the disabled subjects were exploited, but they also, hopefully, helped reframe how some people viewed people with disabilities. These art exhibits may have helped people with abled-bodied privilege become less afraid to look at those who are disabled or to try and change how they act or view people with disability. If these art exhibits did lead to expanding how people with disability are viewed by the mainstream able-bodied population than they exploitation was worth in the large view of the world. Whether or not it was worth it for the disabled subjected used in the pieces is for them to decide. So perhaps instead of deciding whether or not these exhibits, or anything, is exploitation based off of how they affect the larger public we should consider how the affect disabled people. If the people in these pictures feel that they were in some way given a voice, or given a chance to talk about disability in a way that they wanted to then this exploitation is useful.
What really matters when talking about the exploitation of disabled people is how the disabled people feel about their exploitation. LeBesco believes that fat people being proud and loud about their fatness is the first step to fat acceptance. We could look at disability the same way. The first step is not trying to get abled people to accept people with disabilities but trying to get people with disabilities to proudly and vocally accept and celebrate their disability. The key to avoiding exploitation as much as possible is to make sure that disabled people have a space to talk about their disability but also about their life in relation and not in relation to their disability. It’s also important to make the space that they are given to talk about their disability accessible and open to able-bodied people so that they can learn from about disability through people who have a disability.
     It is important to acknowledge that in order for disabled people to not be exploited they will have to represent and talk about themselves using only the power they possess as a marginalized group. Although it is problematic that in the art pieces discussed in Staring: How We Look the disabled people, to some degree, were exploited it is also through this exploitation that they gained fame and were able to reach a wider audience. Is exploitation the price disabled people, and marginalized groups, as a whole must pay to get their message to a wider audience? Currently I think the answer is yes.
I believe we can learn from LeBesco when she writes about disability. Although, LeBesco is specifically focusing on how fatness is a disability a lot of her main ideas can be applied to disability as a whole. LeBesco explains that “positive” fat representation in the media is often related to fatness that is normalized. Similarly we can say that disability is marginalized and hidden in the media and when we do see it we are often encouraged to find that part of the disability that is familiar, or “normal” to us in order to relate to the character. Much like we are encouraged to only like fat people if they are actively trying to get rid of their fat we are taught to like someone with a disability if they are trying to act as much like we are as possible, and ignore their disability, or through pity. I think many of the key ideas LeBesco discusses in “Revolting Bodies” can be useful when discussing disability representation. The key is to give the power and presence to disabled people so that they can be seen, as they want to be seen.
Although their has been a lot of controversy over whether or not American Horror Story’s most current season is exploitive or not I think they do show signs of moving in the right direction by providing interviews with members of the cast who have disabilities. I’ll link to a video below of one member of the cast, Rose Siggins, discussing her life and specifically at one part how she does not want to be exploited and does not view herself as abnormal. Rose demonstrates a way to spread knowledge about disability without exploiting the person who has the disability.


Tuesday, October 7, 2014

Celebrating Fatness


Revolting Bodies By Kathleen LeBesco is ambitious; LeBasco endeavors to cram very complex problems into very short chapters. What’s more within these short chapters she has provoking and involved questions and observations. One idea that stuck with me was in chapter one, when she is discussing why it was that societies idolized fatness in the past. Ultimately the conclusion LeBesco reaches is that fat bodies were idolized because they were hard to attain. She says, “… values aligned with different body sizes largely depend on what is difficult to attain in a given sociocultural and historical context” (LeBesco 21-22). The obvious question I asked myself was why? Today it is easy enough to say that we want bodies that are difficult to obtain because the culture of getting these bodies encouraged consumerism. There are so many different products one can buy to get thinner and fitter. Not only are there products to make yourself thinner but there are also products to make yourself appear thinner. There is an industry that directly benefits from us feeling bad about our bodies and trying to change them. So of course the body that is the hardest to attain is the one that we are socialized to want. But what about in the past?
I suppose there has always been some form of consumerism but it was less prevalent in the time of ancient Greece. The answer to this, I think, is that what is hardest to obtain is scarce, and because it is scarce it is special. It is also worth noting that in both today and in the past the people who most often possess this type of body are wealthy, and are central figures in society because of their wealth. LeBesco’s observation also asserts that we have always wanted what we can’t have. I think this is an important observation because it asserts that for a large part of human history we have been taught to work towards and idolize an image of ourselves that is very hard to obtain. Meaning that it is perhaps time we tired to fight back against this trend. It is about time we tried to change the societal pressure to look like a certain minority of people. But how do we do this? I think one way is by breaking down the stigma that fatness has around it. Mainly the connotations that fat people are unhappy, unhealthy, gluttonous, and bad people. We fight back against this connotation by using representation, and showing fat people who are happy, healthy, and unashamed of their fatness.
In chapter three LeBesco talks a lot about the difference between embracing and celebrating fatness and just admitting that the fat is there. She points out that fat people are often only seen in a positive light if they admit that their fatness is a problem and something they are ashamed of. Only a fat person who dislikes that they’re fat is seen as moral. Fat people who are happy, not in spite of, but because of their fat are seen as incorrect and immoral. On page 47 LeBesco says “Fat moves beyond something we must learn to cope with to something we delight in” she is directly referring to Stinson’s Belly Songs: in Celebration of Fat Women in this section, but this quote is applicable to how we can change the stigma of being fat. Like I said earlier I believe one way we can do this is by showing fat women who celebrate their fatness. But this is something so rarely represented in mainstream media so we must search for it other places.
For me personally my search has mostly been limited to blogs, specifically blogs on the blogging site Tumblr. There are many different body-positivity blogs on Tumblr where users can submit photos of themselves to the blog. I’ll link to a blog that Ifollow on the tumblr that overall celebrates and embraces fatness. [Disclaimer: this blog contains a lot of nudity and some swear words in different descriptions of photos]. 

From body-posi.tumblr.com
What I think is important about this blog is not just that is shows fat bodies, and not just that is shows fat people, but that they are put on display by their own choice. What’s more that they are so unique and different and diverse. There are bodies of different genders, sizes, races; the photos range from high quality to low quality and from fashion level magazine composition to mirror selfies. Another really important part of this blog is not just the diversity but also the happiness and contentment that most of the photos show either through the photo itself or the accompanying description.
Having representation opens up the possibility of identification, or seeing someone and feeling less alone because they look like you. It helps change your mindset when you see someone who looks like you celebrating their body. The first step to changing our views on bodies is to allow ourselves to see different types of bodies, and also to separate our connotations of what kind of people have what kinds of body. We should allow people to celebrate their bodies regardless of their size; and we can start doing this by celebrating our own bodies.

Tuesday, September 23, 2014

"Docile Bodies" and the Pursuit for Impossible Bodies

In the past couple years magazines and advertisers have come under fire for how much they alter photos to sell products. As a result there is also a new trend of making videos showing the transformation photoshopped photos undergo before they are put in magazines. This video shows a woman who is prepped for the photoshoot with extensive hair and makeup, and then altered even more by Photoshop, by the end of the process she looks like a completely different person.
But how does Photoshopped pictures relate to “Foucault, Femininity, and the Modernization of Patriarchal Power”? The section of the article that really got me thinking about these Photoshop videos was section II, where Bartky talks about exercise.  I was struck by her observation that dieting is a form of disciple that makes the body into the enemy. I can recall countless diets that a various family members and friends have tried out throughout the years and just how often these diets made eating restrictive, and difficult. I remember most of my family going to weight watchers will I was growing up and just how often the process of tallying up points and managing how many points they had left made eating stressful. I was also reminded of the several diets that I have attempted throughout my life, and how whenever I was on a diet, suddenly my body did become the enemy, and eating become difficult and painful, as I had to strictly monitor and restrict what I could and could not eat. Not to mention that following the diet plan or not, eating often felt shameful and considering what to eat always require a lot of before hand planning.
However, what really got me thinking about those Photoshop videos was the comment about spot-treatment, and how we have been taught that it is possible to focus on and exercise one particular part of your body, such as your stomach. Bartky points out that spot-treatments are scientifically unsound. This made me question how often we as women feel that we need to strive for an image or idea that might be impossible to reach. For example, no one will ever look like that woman at the end of that video, the original model, and looks almost nothing like the woman at the end of that video. That woman is not modeled after a person, she has been created using technology and there is no way anyone will look exactly like her. How often are we monitoring and changing ourselves to try and look like or conform to an image that is impossible to reach?
owe

 In section IV when Bartky talks about all the beauty rituals we undergo because it is expected that women just want to or are required to do these things in order to be a women; I was thinking about the articles we read for Tuesday’s class about being a Gender Outlaw. Barky at the end of the section points out that makeup is often celebrated as a form of expression, or art. However, unlike typical forms of art, like watercolor, when a woman chooses to not use makeup she receives backlash for not making herself look more feminine. There is a lot of disgust towards women who do not present themselves in a feminine way. For me this adds a new layer of thought to people who are Gender Outlaws. Part of being a “docile body” is that you learn to inscribe gender on yourself from a young age, not only through expression, but also through body language. Through the amount of space you take up and the way you walk. 
These actions and postures are taught from a young age and are often done subconsciously, because of that they can be hard to change. We prescribe gender on to almost everything, how someone looks, how they talk, their body language, the way they treat you. Because of this being a Gender Outlaw takes on a new level of difficulty. Although an individual make identify as a Gender Outlaw, and may present themselves in a gender-neutral way, the rest of the world is going to prescribe a certain gender to them. If that gender is girl than they will be expected to participate in being feminine. As Bartky says “femininity as spectacle is something in which virtually everyone woman is expected to participate in”. If you do not participate, you are incorrectly being a woman, or even perhaps incorrectly being human.


     However, I was thinking that even if one is a Gender Outlaw there is still a lot of body discipline that goes into living and presenting as someone who does not conform to either girl or boy. This discipline of course is not routinized or pushed on you by society the way that femininity is, however, I think it does point out that escaping the tendency to police and alter your body is almost impossible. Changing the way our bodies look and being aware and conscious of how we sit or talk is a large part of how we are raised and how we live. As Foucault pointed out we, regardless of our gender, are regulated by society. From a very young age we are taught to regulate and discipline ourselves. Because of this I think it is currently very difficult and counter intuitive for women to trying and make their bodies fit a certain mold. It is also almost impossible for us to not participate in some form of regulation as it is what we have been doing since childhood.  To change this pressure and regulate our bodies to a certain standard we have to change the system that creates this pressure. We have to change society so that we do not feel as though we always have to monitor and change ourselves to fit in.